Ooey gooey chocolate, crisp edges, and soft centers….nothing is better than a warm cookie straight from the oven! Discover some of the best cookies Fort Wayne, Indiana has to offer and find the best cookie fit for you! 

The Best Cookies in Fort Wayne, Indiana

Iced Sugar Cookie with Sprinkles from Cookie Cottage

Cookie Cottage

From delectable oatmeal chocolate chip cookies, and snickerdoodles to specialty favorites like double chocolate chip mint and georgie pies, Cookie Cottage is a cookie lover's heaven!  In their new location, pick out a dozen or two. The only hard part is deciding what flavors to try!

620 W Washington Center Rd. | (260) 471-6678


Insomnia Cookies

Ever in need of a late night sweet treat? Well, Insomnia Cookies is the perfect place for you. From their endless menu consisting of cookie cakes, mini cookies, witches, 17 different cookie flavors and a vegan cookie option, to being open until 1 am, Insomnia Cookies is a great stop offering flexibility in their menu and hours.

840 Calhoun St, Fort Wayne, IN 46802 | (260) 333-5101


Dirty Dough Cookies

Dirty Dough is a crowd favorite offering unique cookie creations such as stuffed chocolate chip, brookie, raspberry toaster tart, the reverse, cookies n creme, and most exciting of all, a weekly mystery cookie.

1525 W Dupont Rd, Fort Wayne, IN 46825 | (260) 414-7192


Crumbl Cookie

With new flavors every week, you’ll never get tired of the fresh made and insanely unique cookies that crumbl cookie has to offer.

433 W Coliseum Blvd | 1034 Thomas Road Suite 116


GK Baked Goods

GK offers delicious coffee along with fresh croissants and muffins. However, their giant chocolate chip cookie must take the cake for best chocolate chip cookie around. It is baked to perfection, crunchy on the outside and soft and gooey on the inside, how could you not want to try this cookie? 

202 W Berry St Suite 120, Fort Wayne, IN 46802


Sweets on Main

Typically, Sweets on Main is known for their delicious cakes and ice cream, but their warm cookie topped with ice cream that Sweets on Main serves is to die for. You can choose from a warm double chocolate brownie or upgrade to whatever specialty sweet treat you prefer. Following this, you would choose your flavor of ice cream and lastly, top it off by adding whip cream, syrups, and candy! 

123 W Main St, Fort Wayne, IN 46802 | (260) 424-0244


Courtney’s Bakery

If you're north of downtown Fort Wayne, make a stop in at Courtney's Bakery on Coldwater Road. Courtney's has some of the best cakes and cupcakes in town, but they also tout cookies and macarons on their menu! They also serve vegan and gluten free options for those in need of substitutions! 

7773 Coldwater Rd. | (260) 338-2688


Child picking out a complimentary cookie at the Fort Wayne International Airport
@amykristaminnich on Instagram

Fun Fact: The Fort Wayne International Airport serves Cookies!

The Fort Wayne International Airport wins the best hospitality for their sweet "Welcome Home" cookies. From getting home on a late-night flight or being welcomed by their greeters, make sure you don't miss the opportunity to snag a package of cookies on your way to baggage claim!

3801 W Ferguson Rd. | (260) 747-4146

This blog was originally published in November 2018 and has been updated. Updated May 2024.