Mike’s Top Five Fort Wayne Hamburgers

I eat out. A lot. If you’ve been following my posts, you know that already. While I’ve focused on particular restaurants thus far, I thought I’d do something a little different this time out. I’m starting a series of posts I call my “Favorite Fives.” Each list will be – you guessed it – my five favorite foods in a particular category.

Entrées, appetizers, desserts, you name it, I have a list for it. Some posts may be pretty detailed, some may just hit you with the facts. The first list is one of the latter and equally the easiest and the most difficult for me to assemble: my favorite five hamburgers. The beauty of hamburgers is that they’re like snowflakes…no two are quite the same.

5.         Lunch Box Café Hamburger

It’s the burger with history! The Lunch Box Café uses Gardner’s Drive Inn’s original recipe. Gardner’s, once the place to see and be seen in Fort Wayne, lives on through this sandwich.

Learn more about the Lunch Box Café

4.         Five Guys Bacon Cheeseburger

This is a burger I first discovered in Charlottesville, Virginia, and was thrilled when the chain came to Fort Wayne. These burgers are a mouthful – order a “little cheeseburger” for a single patty (plenty of food for most people I know). And boy, do you get a lot of fries. A regular order can feed two. Get ‘em Cajun style for some extra kick.

Learn more about Five Guys

gas house 300x225 Mikes Top Five Fort Wayne Hamburgers

Don Hall's Gas House is one of many Fort Wayne locations where you can find the Big Buster!

3.         Hall’s Big Buster

It’s a burger I’ve mentioned before and one that’s a hometown favorite.

Learn more about Don Hall’s

2.         Penguin Point’s Super Wally

I recently re-discovered Penguin Point, and I’m kicking myself for all the time we’ve spent apart. It’s the Wally Sauce that makes this burger, and coupled with a side of crinkly fries and a soda, it’s nearly the perfect meal.

Learn more about Penguin Point

1.         Culver’s ButterBurger with Cheese

A burger lover’s delight, the buttered bun and fresh toppings (I get mine with ketchup, mustard, lettuce, pickle, and onion) make this one my favorite. Culver’s has great sides, too, my favorites being the onion rings and Wisconsin cheese curds.

Learn more about Culver’s

Mike

About

Apart from spending his college years in West Lafayette, Indiana, and Dayton, Ohio, Mike Flohr is a lifetime resident of the Summit City. Today he divides his time among his wife, Megan, his job as a college librarian, and his many geek obsessions.

5 Responses to “Mike’s Top Five Fort Wayne Hamburgers”

    Alan
    February 8th, 2012
    Great choices, Mike. I would like to add a couple that I have enjoyed recently. Here's a surprise: stop by the Oyster Bar on Calhoun St. for lunch and grab one of their burgers. They are juicy and have a nice fresh, beefy taste that you expect from a nice cut of beef, like a steak. They are very creative with their toppings, so expect to see a wide variety of veggies, or perhaps even a burger topped with crab meat and cheese! Another tip: try them on Tuesdays. They usually have "$2 Tuesdays" where you can get one of their great burgers for, well, $2. As far a chain goes, I like the bleu cheese burger at Red Robin in Glenbrook Mall. Now, the prices really aren't a bargain here, expect to pay about $12 bucks for a burger, fries, and soda. The burgers are, however, big enough to feed a horse, and the service has always been good. And there you go. Two more burgers to consider.
    Renee
    Renee
    February 8th, 2012
    I completely forget about Penguin Point! We're going to HAVE to stop by there this weekend.
    Brad Davis
    February 8th, 2012
    What, no Powers' Hamburgers?? I am shocked! They are the freshest, most tender, tastiest little morsels of heaven you can buy. Add a bowl of chili, chips and a pop and I am good to go!
    Mike Benny
    March 27th, 2012
    Hi Mike! Do you mind if I re-post this on my site? Funny - I Google Mike's Top Five and end up here! Let me know if it's okay with you.
    mike
    February 24th, 2013
    live beyond your local eateries. butter burger? really?

Leave a Comment